One way to view the construction of market neutral portfolios is through the lens of CAPM, through which we can model returns on an asset as
\(R_i = \beta_i (R_m – R_f) + R_f +\alpha_i \)
where beta is the sensitivity of an asset’s return, as fit through simple linear regression, to the market excess return, and alpha is the abnormal, or excess return of the asset. Alpha would also be known as an error term in stricter linear regression terminology. It represents yet unexplained portions of the return and that will be relevant later in this post.
Consider a pairs trading scheme. We know that in pairs trading, a simple form of statistical arbitrage could be used to always short one stock and long the other. One could model the return of the portfolio consisting of a pair as:
\(R_p = R_1 – R_2 = (\beta_1-\beta_2)\cdot(R_m – R_f) + R_f – R_f + \alpha_1-\alpha_2\)
If we assume that the pair has been chosen skillfully, and, that for whatever reasons such as fundamental alignment, it is safe to assume that each stock has an equal beta to the other, then the equation above collapses to:
\(R_p = 0 \cdot (R_m – R_f) + 0 + \alpha_1 – \alpha_2\)
\(R_p = \alpha_1 – \alpha_2\)
Wrapping the resulting equation in some syntactic sugar from probability theory, we get:
\(E[R_p] = E[\alpha_1] – E[\alpha_2]\)
So we see that the return of such a portfolio doesn’t depend on market conditions at all, and relies entirely on the abnormal return.
Since we are shorting asset 2, we would only do so when its alpha is expected to be negative. And since we are going long on asset 1, we would want our position to coincide with its positive expected return so that the net return on our portfolio is only ever positive.
If we consider that alpha factors often manifest in a cross sectional manner, we can see that it would be reasonable to define alpha in terms of a single dimension or axis, mathematically speaking.
In other words we are free to quantify alpha for both stocks in the portfolio on just one formula/metric/KPI so that we know to go long on the stock with a higher value on this metric and to go short on the one with a lower value.
That’s it for my post for now. I’m totally open to questions. Especially if something is unclear. It helps me think things through further.